It’s an enticing day dream. I am swinging gently in a hammock, a hat shading my face, with a book and an icy sangria, as the sun beats down on me.
“Knock,knock, remember me?” It’s him, the Owl.
“It’s been a while,” I nod, irritated my reverie has been disturbed. And, also, that reality sucks. I look up at the mound of spring cleaning that needs to be done around the house and realise the hammock scene is just a mirage.
“So will you be celebrating today, with perhaps a Sangria?” he asks, tongue-in-cheek.
I wince. But my temper rises. “Perhaps not. It was to be an important day if the Women’s Reservation Bill had been passed in the Parliament. Imagine one-third of the nation’s decisions will be in the hands of women.”
“Will it help?” he asks making a space for himself among the blankets and duvets and other winter furnishings.
“Won’t it?” I ask, wrapping the woollens in camphor and plastic sheets.
“How?”
“ Women will bring down the scale of violence, usher in cleaner politics, do away with political vendetta, better governance and a touch of care into the whole dirty business of politics?” I say.
He laughs. It’s a sharp derisive one.
“Reservation for economically backward groups in education and government jobs for over decades has helped the disadvantaged groups”, I point out.
“But at the cost of dividing the people; destabilising social fabric into antagonistic groups, bringing down the value of merit”, he says. “And oh, did you notice that the men who acted like goons and objected to the women’s bill in the Indian Parliament were the same men who have received the benefits of quota and caste politics?” asks the Owl.
“It’s Orwellian law I suppose. Some will be mightier than others. Remember Animal Farm?” I ask.
“The purpose of inclusiveness is jeopardised by the quota system in the name of affirmative politics as it only helps create another set of elite who have emerged from the ashes of the previous group of privileged people,” says the Owl.
“The Indian subcontinent has thrown up the highest number of women prime ministers in the history of modern world”, I say.
“From Hasina, to Benazir to Indira to Chandrika, these women assumed their country’s premier’s post through their associations with the memory of a dead parent or spouse. Their track record has proved the sceptics and misogynists right that to be a true leader of a nation your gender is irrelevant,” elaborates the Owl. “The quality of India’s women leaders has not exactly been inspiring,” he says.
“As of today women form some 8 % of Indian Parliament ;while in the US between the Senate and House of Representatives it is a mere 13%”, I say.
“And 23% of women form Afghanisatan’s political leadership, but the condition of women in the country needs no mention”, he points out.
“Volume doesn’t matter, is it?”I ask.
“No, especially if the quantity dilutes quality”, he says.
“We won’t suffer in silence for longer,” I warn.
“Numbers are for making noise”, he says, making a smooth exit as I aim a bar of detergent at his head.


bloody brilliant i say
and happy women’s day maami….unreservedly U rule….
(Thanks for your appreciation, without reservations)
Good one Maami! Happy Women’s day to you. I would rather not have one-third of the parliament filled with people like Phoolan Devi and Mayawathi.
Our country has always chosen to appease sections of it’s citizens by means of reservations rather than striving to provide equal opportunity to all to excel.
(Cheers)
I have a very similar themed post in my drafts, so dont accuse me of plagiarism later. Plus I’m not Aamir Khan and I’m a lot taller. let’s just put it as two great minds, same think…
(Great people think alike on small matters, I say!)
So the hand is looking better I guess. The mind is as fresh as ever
(looks nasty, feels better)
brilliant i say!
(
)Nice post for Women’s Day, maami. But the “quality” of the women politician is also dependent on their education. Let’s have more than lip service to women’s education in backward and or rural ares and we will see how the how it improves everything from civic aminities/infrastucture to real freedom/power of women themselves. But let’s go with numbers for now…
(True)
‘as I aim a bar of detergent at his head.’ superb.A pleasure reading your posts .Always.
Btw,I am pretty sure ,there will be International Under 13 Girls Day,Under 18 girls day and such ,promoted by Greeting Card sellers in the near future.so much for Days and their importance….
(Need your vote for Maami’s Day saar)
Maami,
I put a link to this website and this particular posting on my facebook account. Hope you don’t mind.
(Never mind
)Good one and can’t agree with you more. Sadly., reservation has become the bane of India – looks like we need a movement to get out of its shackles.
(Ah, well)
[...] This seat is reserved and More women, more power? Two interesting posts on Women reservation bill in India. Its a shame that the bill is not [...]
Well put! Such high level politics has no gender associations. There is a certain set of qualities that is necessary to be at the top of the political world, and those who possess those qualities will be on top, regardless of gender. Golda Meir, Indira Gandhi, Margaret Thatcher etc have been extremely violent, brought no touch of care or anything else. Those positions demand such players. That’s all. If our country wants to become a developed nation, what we need to do is to reduce government involvement, and not look to increase it.
(In India where family connections and dynastic politics rule, there is a danger that more women from affluent politician’s family will get to fill the seats at the Parliament level)
Good one! Completely agree!
(
)Women on top is an attractive proposition
It has my support 
However empowerment should begin at village leadership levels and go uo the social ladder.
(That is the litmus test. Apart from a handful of panchayats run by women and say like a state in Kerala there is a lot to be done for empowerment of women at local levels. That’s is an uphill task)
*up*
well.. happy women’s day maami! totally agree with your post.. well soon, one-third of the country’s decisions will be taken by women!
By the way.. good to see your hand has recovered to type back!!!
(
)Somehow, I agree with the owl. Doesn’t make a difference now, does it?
Ohh and before you get all feminist on me maami, i was born on the 8th of march
Most, most brilliant
(
)That the most vociferous opponents to the bill have been the beneficiary of a reservation of another kind is what puzzles me. What are they threatened by?
I am so glad you are back with this post – proof that the hand has healed.
Or have you been a bad girl and straining it?
(Bad girl vonly)
hear hear – brilliant!
(Ah, the sun shines on me after a long time
)Oversimplification, don’t you think?
(Yes, getting lazy)
hmm. thought provoking… i just hope this doesn’t give the likes of lallu to drag all his 7 daughters into politics, as his puppets!!!
on the other hand, maybe, just maybe it will bring down the female infanticide rates….
btw, u shd be on facebook!
(I am unable to do facebook, all because of you vonly)
Haven’t seen any difference to women in the Gram Panchayats/ Municipality wards where candidature is reserved for women (Live in a rural zone, so qualified to say this:)).
(Read an interesting article in Indian Express yesterday on a clutch of villages that have female sarpanches.
But as you say rare for caste and gender walls to come down for say a Thakur/Thevar village male elder to accept a Dalit female sarpanch etc)
Nice to see you back! Your Owl mouths bitter words. So, it is the truth:-)
(
)Dear Owl,
Its nice to have you back! Maami, ahem…I think the bill is symbolic as it should be. Yes our times have progressed, in a time when the girl child is born in rajasthan , schemes like Laadli are availed of and then the child is murdered. And we say that this reservation is wrong??????
(In an ideal world there ought to be no reservation. But there’s no ideal world. Reservations for 60 years have helped in a lot of social levelling, but at the bottom level work is very tough, empowerment a gruelling social task for say tribes and SC/STs with those who reaped the benefits of reservation turning to be the new elite. I would like to cheer and hope that the many actresses and wives/spouses of rich politicians at the Parliament will help the poor woman with lousy wages, no health care, and violence at the very bottom of the social and gender pit. This will definetly lift aspirations of women, for that I am happy)
Very well written and thought provoking .Reservations from public transport to parliament ! On the other hand we talk about womens rights.Why cant it just be equal opportunity if ever such a concept exists in reality?
(Alas it doesn’t exist hence the fight)
Nice to see you back Maami . Ah really , what are we the rest of the year ? And what is Women’s Day doing for the underprivileged woman ? A puzzle , there , like so many others
(
)Maami, meaning no disrespect to women whatsoever, won’t this bill lead people to discount the success of those women who achieve it by virtue of their own efforts as against those who grab on to the rungs of the ladder of reservation? Also, the Constitution forbids discrimination on any basis, and this certainly is tantamount to discrimination.
I do see the rationale behind drafting the reservation bills but far from seeing the necessary changes in the status of the oppressed sections of the society, they have further divided it and antagonised one section against the other. And our bottom-feeder politicians never cease to take advantage of the situation. Reservations clearly haven’t worked in India and they never will. A social awakening is the panacea to all woes!
(
)Awesomely brilliant, I must say! The whole discussion and esp. the end, vintage mami…(well, this post suggests your hand is better and ready to take on the world..again!)
(Will you shake hands with me saar?)
Thanks maami for the nice thought provoking post.
Why not take the example of countries such as Sweden and Norway that have reservation for women (for men too for that matter) to have equal representation? I see that too many primary school teachers are women and perhaps we need men there. While admitting innate differences, women can bring in diversity of ideas and implementation. People criticise the ruthlessness of women leaders but I havent seen a woman hitler, stalin or polpot.
“And 23% of women form Afghanisatan’s political leadership, but the condition of women in the country needs no mention”, he points out”
Yes, but I am sure it is for the better even if you dont see the effects immeadietly.
Gender inequality cannot be eliminated with any bill but at least as a mark of representation this reservation is good. There might be bad representatives in this lot. That’s another story I believe.
An interesting statistic would be a familial mapping between the male MPs and the women who get elected through these reservations. The mapping might be one to one to start with. The empowerment as of now is happening only top-down approach rather than a bottom to top approach. That is why we have an Indira Gandhi, Sonia Gandhi, Kanimozhi, Vasundhara, Priya Dutt. The bottom level empowerment can only be through education and economic independence.
There are dynasties in politics now just like in medieval times and the fight is between them. The candidates seem to matter less than the dynasty from which he/she comes from. Look at Azhagiri, KaniMozhi, the Marans. Karunanidhi once said “Party is family”. Now ” Family is the party”. Empowerment in such a scenario is a far cry. I don’t know if there would be a dramatic change in the situation after the bill bit hey symbolically its great. I am sure there are amazons out there.