We had guests for dinner on Sunday and among them was a couple from Karachi and their cherubic 2 year-old.
I am usually chilled as I’ve creased out the dinner-for-dummies schedule. This time I went into doubt.”Is it appropriate to bring out a bottle of wine? Should I replace it with lemonades and sodas? Push the South-Indian vegetarian menu, I cheat at, off the table? Order in a biriyani? Do I tog out in a sari? Remove the chubby Krishna Mysores off the wall-too Hindu, willy-showing and all? Say something, no”, I clucked.
“Let me get him Dalrymple’s book as a gift”, Mister said, ever-at-ease, ignoring my squawking.
Mir, (for convenience sake), sported a salt and pepper beard. His handsome visage indicated his Pathan ancestry, a terrific nose, chiselled mouth and piercing Afghani eyes and a friendly demeanour. He pressed a huge bouquet of flowers into my hand and downed his single malt with practised ease. His Begum looked very much a Delhi Muhajir and was in a Fab India ensemble, sleek Dolce and Gabbana spectacles, sported a chic bob and preferred a, “Vodka with Coke, please”.
At our feet, sat their junior, saying “Whirrrr” to an assortment of toy cars and the Begum, in a Mother Hen fashion, periodically shoved in a spoonful of pulav and dal into his mouth.
My run-in with the old-enemy-country folk, in the past, had been freezingly polite.
The first brush had been more than a decade ago in Germany, with a Pakistani working out of Berlin, who was part of our professional contingent. He was polished, spoke flawless German, and some Hindi. We did hang out one afternoon at the Zeughaus, the German Historical Museum, when we were at a loose-end from work. He showed me around the place, marking out the sights and answering my questions patiently.I had found him friendly, well-mannered and courteous, but equally wary and distant. We didn’t exchange numbers while saying our goodbyes.
A couple of years later, we were at a conference in London and the conglomeration was graced by a nephew of a Pakistani premier. He refused to look at us group of Indians and his colleague, a lady lawyer from Islamabad, condescended to share the sub-continental table with us. Her only comment during the luncheon session was how, “We ladies would never dress your way or drink this way”, jutting her chin at our trousers and jackets and skirts. We had choked silently into our glasses, unsure of retorting, while B had shot back:”Yeah, who wants to wear a sari in this blighted cold”.
In retrospect, those were pre-bus rides times; when cricket matches were gladiatorial, and neither country had the smugness of acquired nukes or made efforts to ease the pressure at the leadership and commoner levels. Raw, unsure and impatient, we held on to our collective native prides and kept a frosty distance away from each other for the rest of the conference. The only thing that helped keep my prejudice down was a chance run-in with the half-Pakistani writer Hanif Kureshi.But then, bowled over by his works as I was, I considered him more a cosmopolitan Londoner of the 1990s than a true-blue Pakistani writer.
Mir Jr toddled up and hopped trying to scale the walls.”He wants to touch the glittering work”, Mir laughed, pointing to the portly cherub Krishna holding aloft a butter ball. “Egg”, lisped Mir Jr and we laughed. “The Sri Krishna is beautiful”, the Begum complimented. My bleeding heart bled further.
They ran us through their itinerary. Visiting family in UP, (”Our family homes on either side of the border are preserved”), and meeting with friends, and more friends. Assorted chachas, chachis, nanis and dadis lived on either side and have been lost to each other. Young ones, who managed to procure visas, like them, come by at odd intervals. Partition?”A needless division of families”.
What were they doing on the night of Benazir’s death?
“He was hard at work; and she kept vigil at home over family, bolting doors as there was mayhem oustide. Despite her many faults, she consistently resisted the military establishment and was a thin hope for some semblance of a democractic set up”, Mir said, adding, “Unlike you, we have not had a functional democracy for ages”.
What is the night life in Pakistan like?
“Swinging”, grinned Mir, and proceeded to give us details of the many mujras of their high streets that made our Bombay dance bars look tame.
They tucked into the kheema curry and kuler achar and rotis with relish and asked, “Did you cook all this?”
“No, I didn’t”, I replied.
“She’s a vegetarian”, A, our friend, supplied with a chuckle, “She’s from south where they are strict about it”.
Will they catch up with Bollywood while here? A Jodha Akbar perhaps?
“Nah, I want to watch Om Shanti Om, I adore Shah Rukhji“, the Begum said, turning dreamy-eyed.
“And which part of the south are you from?” Mir enquired.
“Madras”.
“Do you make movies there, like Bollywood?”
“We sure do. Some of them have acted in Bollywood too”. I hummed the Sadma song ,’Ei zindagi gale laga le’.
“Oh, I think I know that one. The heroine is cuckoo in it. And this same hero sang an English song with a heroine in a lift in a strange accent…” (thanks SPB) “and later fell off a cliff into the sea with his girlfriend because they were star-crossed lovers”.
She hummed back, ‘teri mere beech mei’.
“That’s Ek Duje ke Liye and he’s our top star, Kamalahasan,” I never sounded prouder.
“Hasan? From our mulk?” Oops, no, but ever listen to A. R.Rahman?
We closed the night with the Begum doing a fantastic impersonation of Musharaff strutting his stuff; A took off on Pranab Mukherjee’s Bonglish; R on Laloo’s itchy and scratchy one-liners, and yours truly did a J.Jayalalithaa.

Glad to read a relaxed piece instead of the usual Pakki bashing stuff.
“Hasan? From our mulk?” That was nice!
Even here in the US, most of my run-ins with the “old enemy country” has been limited, but most of them have been refreshingly positive. When we formed a rag-tag cricket team to play in the local leagues, this dude from Peshawar who was doing a Phd in Physics came in and wanted to play with us. It caused a few idiots to have a heart attack and swear off all contact with the team if he was included, but the guy turned out to be a gem. During one long drive, he told us about Peshawar, their fascination with all things Indian (particularly movies) and the fact that common people back in Pakistan were probably similar to their brothers in India. That probably won a few minds over. Also he was a good all rounder, that Tariq.
During a short stay at an International Hostel In Manchester, we encountered a similar guarded politeness from our Pakistani neighbours.
So I was quite surprised to find the warmth of the Taxi driver from karachi in dubai who insisted on calling me behen and kept telling me that we are all from the same country.
When my son was in pakistan two years ago covering the cricket matches, he was overwhelmed by their hospitality and warmth.
it seems that ordinary citizens on both sides of the border are willing to look past the historic animosities and just treat each other as neighbours with a common past. The problem seems to be for the politicians, intelligentia and journalists?
(Siddharta Vaidyanathan, your sonny boy?)
And oh, an impression of JJ – and people say she is inimitable.
i suppose i am the most experienced here. instead of the one off meetings, i have been living with one for the past 8 months and i tell you, she is the akka that i always longed for all my life.
it is so much more different, when you have to deal with the situation on a daily basis, especially with the history we share. opinions are varied , yet similar. in discussions, there are some lines you cross and others you don’t, but you find those lines only after the tresspass. but apart from these run-ins, i find that there is no difference. we are the same people.
(sisters of a different order sharing the same roof-interesting)
What should I do to be invited to such a party?
(Must sing, tipple and laugh aloud)
You tube / Podcast anyone?
(I’m throwing a burka over my face)
Nice one there. My interaction with Pakis has been limited to the beauty parlor lady who offers small talk while she does my eyebrows. I found that they live like us, love hindi movies, tired of their politicians and corruption (just like us). When I walked out that day, I remember wondering to myself, why we consider ourselves sworn enemies..
(and u can never have secrets with the beauty parlour ladies he he)
Bowled over! Enjoy reading it and look forward for more:).
Swing while you’re winning as they say….
Mujhras eh? Pretty interestin… I’d rather prefer a compilation of item numbers in a villains lair from the movies of the 90s than watch buxom lookalikes of rambha gyrating to some loud n jarring moosik in a karachi basement party…
swing you say? man! i think that tilts the scales…..
(You think Robbie Williams doing a Rehmatullah won’t work eh?)
[...] Maami blogs about a dinner with her guests from Pakistan. I’m borrowing her post title! What were they doing on the night of Benazir’s death? [...]
Good one.
I have a Paki friend too, here in the US. Pretty positive I must say. He refers to all Indians and Pakis as “desi bhais”.
And yeah, he loves Salman Khan and Virender Sehwag – the love for the latter arising because the aforementioned gentleman is a Shoaib hater and he remembers Sehwag thrashing him around during India’s 2004 tour of Pakistan.
yes,siddhartha is the sonny boy.
Wow! I’ve never met a Pakistani, but I do feel all these hostilities have been nurtured by politicians with agendas….
I have a few pakistani friends. We have a lot more in common than not, when we are away from our respective homelands. By the way, my mother went to school with Jayalalitha. She does a pretty mean impression of her too.
(Good old Church Park eh??)
Friendly neighbours aside, the blogosphere demands youtube video/podcast of The Maami JJ Impersonation
(Aiyo, it will be quite a sight ya
)Aa nalla inch mae. Ippa suberaa innonnu eydhi thallunga paakalaam.
@usha.
Well, what a small world it is we inhabit. I ran into your boy outside the MCG a couple of days before the Boxing Day test. Ask him if he remembers a dad with two children in tow-that was me!
@10 yearslate:
Yes he does!
Ashok’s demand is reasonable, maami.
Vox populi, vox dei.
(Anna naaman vazhga, puratchi thalaivar naamam vazhgha
)such an endearing ramble. thanks for sharing this.
regards,
asuph
(thanks)
Maami, Is there an audio upload of ‘yours truly’ enacting J.Jayalalitha ? I want to listen to that. This is a wonderful post. There have been only few posts which I have not been read by me on your blog. I will finish them soon.
(Thanks for your interest. And no, no audio/video upload of JJ…think I’ve forgotten how she sounds. She’s been too silent in recent times!)
Hi,
I’m from Karachi. My parents belong to India.
In Pakistan the educated people especially Urdu, Sindhi and Baloch speaking people do not hate Indian people.
As far as I know the well educated class of India would not hate Pakistani people.
Mainly the politicians and the Military and Civil Bureaucracies who spread the hatred and complexities the issues between these countries.
If both countries can do an agreement for a term of 15 years for no military intervention and focus n people development then both countries will flourish and have control their internal issues and satisfy their people and improve their lives.
This requires the awareness in people and keeps pressure on their governments.
(Thanks for dropping by)